How to Engage in Shared Decision-Making P7C

by

Empowering Your Health Journey: A Practical Guide to Shared Decision-Making (P7C)

Navigating healthcare can often feel like a solo expedition, where information is abundant but true understanding and control remain elusive. Yet, a more collaborative and ultimately more effective approach exists: Shared Decision-Making (SDM). This isn’t just a buzzword; it’s a fundamental shift in how you interact with your healthcare team, transforming you from a passive recipient of care into an active, informed partner. This guide will equip you with the practical tools and actionable strategies to confidently engage in SDM, specifically focusing on the P7C framework – a robust model for effective health discussions.

The P7C framework, though not an official, universally recognized acronym, can be interpreted as a practical mnemonic to guide comprehensive shared decision-making. For the purposes of this guide, we’ll expand on its potential, using it as a scaffold to build actionable strategies for effective health conversations.

Understanding the P7C Framework: Your SDM Compass

While the precise meaning of P7C can vary, let’s conceptualize it as a powerful mnemonic to structure your shared decision-making conversations. We’ll interpret it as follows:

  • Problem/Purpose: Clearly define the health issue and the goal of the discussion.

  • Perspective: Understand the different viewpoints involved – yours, your clinician’s, and perhaps your family’s.

  • Pros and Cons: Explore the benefits and drawbacks of each available option.

  • Preferences: Articulate your values, beliefs, and what truly matters to you.

  • Probability: Understand the likelihood of different outcomes for each option.

  • Plan: Jointly develop a clear course of action.

  • Protocol for Change/Review: Establish how decisions will be revisited and adjusted.

  • Confidence: Assess your comfort and certainty with the chosen path.

This framework provides a systematic way to ensure all critical aspects of a health decision are addressed. Let’s dive into how to practically apply each element.

Preparing for Shared Decision-Making: Laying the Groundwork

Effective SDM doesn’t just happen; it’s cultivated. Your preparation is key to a productive conversation.

1. Identify Your Core Concerns and Questions (Problem/Purpose)

Before you even step into a clinic, take time to reflect. What is the central health issue you’re facing? What do you hope to achieve from this appointment or discussion? Be as specific as possible.

Actionable Steps:

  • Journaling: Dedicate a notebook or digital document to your health concerns. Write down symptoms, how they affect your daily life, and any questions that come to mind.
    • Example: Instead of “My stomach hurts,” write “My stomach pain is a sharp, burning sensation that occurs primarily after meals and worsens when I lie down. It’s making it difficult to sleep and enjoy food. I want to understand what’s causing it and how to reduce the pain so I can get back to my regular activities.”
  • Prioritize Questions: You might have many questions. Rank them in order of importance. This helps ensure you cover the most critical points, especially if time is limited.
    • Example: If you’re discussing a new medication, your top questions might be: “What are the most common side effects?”, “How will this interact with my other medications?”, and “How long will I need to take it?” Less critical might be “Where is the medication manufactured?”
  • Bring a Support Person (If Desired): A trusted family member or friend can act as an extra set of ears, take notes, and help you remember key points. Discuss your goals with them beforehand so they can effectively support you.
    • Example: If your spouse is accompanying you, tell them, “My main goal today is to understand why my blood pressure is high and what my options are for lowering it. Can you help me remember to ask about diet changes and exercise, not just medication?”

2. Research and Gather Initial Information (Perspective)

While your clinician is the expert, being informed empowers you to ask better questions and understand explanations more deeply. This isn’t about self-diagnosing, but about building a foundational understanding.

Actionable Steps:

  • Reliable Sources Only: Stick to reputable health organizations (e.g., World Health Organization, national health services, university medical centers) for information. Avoid sensationalist websites or forums as your primary source.
    • Example: If researching diabetes, look at websites from the American Diabetes Association or the National Institutes of Health, not personal blogs claiming miracle cures.
  • Understand Basic Terminology: Look up medical terms you might encounter. This helps demystify the conversation.
    • Example: Before a cardiology appointment, you might research “atherosclerosis,” “hypertension,” or “cholesterol levels” so you’re not lost when these terms are used.
  • Don’t Overwhelm Yourself: The goal is to be informed, not to become a medical expert. Focus on understanding the general condition and common treatment approaches.
    • Example: If considering knee surgery, understand the general procedure, recovery time, and common risks. You don’t need to know every surgical technique detail.

During the Consultation: Engaging Effectively

This is where SDM comes alive. Your active participation is crucial.

1. Clearly State Your Purpose and Expectations (Problem/Purpose)

Start by clearly articulating why you’re there and what you hope to achieve from the conversation. This sets the stage for a focused discussion.

Actionable Steps:

  • Opening Statement: Begin with a concise summary of your concerns.
    • Example: “Dr. Lee, I’m here today because I’ve been experiencing persistent headaches, and I’m hoping to understand the cause and explore treatment options. My main goal is to reduce their frequency and intensity so I can resume my daily activities without interruption.”
  • Express Your Desire for SDM: Explicitly state that you want to be an active participant in the decision-making process.
    • Example: “I’d really appreciate it if we could discuss all the available options and weigh them together, so I can make an informed decision that aligns with my lifestyle.”
  • Listen Actively: Pay full attention to your clinician’s explanations. Don’t interrupt unless absolutely necessary for clarification.
    • Example: Instead of formulating your next question while they’re speaking, focus on understanding their current point.

2. Elicit Your Clinician’s Perspective (Perspective)

Understanding your clinician’s viewpoint, their expertise, and their initial thoughts on your condition is vital.

Actionable Steps:

  • Ask Open-Ended Questions: Encourage more than just a “yes” or “no” answer.
    • Example: Instead of “Is this serious?”, ask “Based on what you’ve observed, what are your initial thoughts on the potential causes of my symptoms?” or “What’s your professional assessment of my condition and its potential trajectory?”
  • Understand Their Rationale: Ask why they are suggesting a particular course of action or diagnosis.
    • Example: “Could you explain why you believe this specific medication is the best first step for my condition, compared to other options?” or “What led you to that particular diagnosis?”
  • Acknowledge and Reflect: Show that you’re understanding their perspective by briefly summarizing what they’ve said.
    • Example: “So, if I understand correctly, you’re suggesting that my fatigue could be related to my thyroid, and you want to run blood tests to confirm that, correct?”

3. Explore All Available Options and Their Pros and Cons (Pros and Cons)

This is the core of shared decision-making. Don’t settle for the first option presented. Insist on understanding the full spectrum of choices.

Actionable Steps:

  • Request All Valid Options: Ask about all clinically appropriate courses of action, including watchful waiting, lifestyle changes, medication, surgery, and alternative therapies (if relevant and evidence-based).
    • Example: “Beyond medication, what other approaches could we consider for managing my high cholesterol? Are there specific dietary changes or exercise routines that could be effective?”
  • Discuss Benefits for Each Option: For every option, ask about its potential positive outcomes.
    • Example: “What are the expected benefits of this surgery for my knee pain? How much pain relief can I realistically expect, and what’s the likelihood of regaining full mobility?”
  • Discuss Risks and Side Effects for Each Option: It’s equally important to understand the downsides. Be specific.
    • Example: “What are the common side effects of this antidepressant? Are there any serious but rare side effects I should be aware of? What’s the risk of addiction?”
  • Consider the “Do Nothing” Option: Sometimes, the best course of action is to monitor and wait. Discuss the implications of not intervening.
    • Example: “What would happen if we didn’t pursue any treatment for this condition right now? What are the potential risks and benefits of a ‘watch and wait’ approach?”
  • Use Decision Aids (If Available): Many healthcare systems offer decision aids – tools that present information about different treatment options in an easy-to-understand format, often with visuals and comparisons. Ask if any are available for your condition.
    • Example: “Do you have any patient decision aids or brochures that compare the different treatment options for my lower back pain?”

4. Articulate Your Personal Preferences and Values (Preferences)

Your life, your priorities. This is where your unique circumstances come into play. What matters most to you in terms of quality of life, daily activities, and long-term goals?

Actionable Steps:

  • Identify Your Priorities: Before the appointment, think about what aspects of your life a health decision might impact. Is it your ability to work, care for family, pursue hobbies, or maintain a certain lifestyle?
    • Example: “My ability to play with my grandchildren is incredibly important to me. How might these different treatment options for my arthritis affect my energy levels and mobility in the long run?”
  • Communicate Your “Non-Negotiables”: Are there certain risks you absolutely cannot tolerate, or side effects that would significantly compromise your quality of life?
    • Example: “I’m very concerned about anything that might impact my cognitive function, as my job requires a high level of mental clarity. How do these options stack up in that regard?”
  • Discuss Lifestyle Impact: How will the treatment integrate into your daily routine?
    • Example: “I travel frequently for work. How would a treatment requiring daily infusions fit into that schedule?” or “I’m a keen marathon runner. How might this recovery period impact my training schedule?”
  • Consider Financial Implications: While not always the primary factor, cost can be a significant concern. Don’t hesitate to bring it up.
    • Example: “Are there significant cost differences between these options, and how might my insurance cover them?”

5. Understand Probabilities and Likelihoods (Probability)

Move beyond vague statements. Ask for concrete numbers or ranges when discussing outcomes, risks, and success rates.

Actionable Steps:

  • Request Statistical Data: Ask about the percentage chance of success, the likelihood of side effects, or the probability of a recurrence.
    • Example: “What’s the success rate for this type of surgery for someone with my specific condition and age?” or “What’s the probability of experiencing significant nausea with this chemotherapy regimen?”
  • Clarify What “Rare” or “Common” Means: A clinician might say a side effect is “rare,” but that could mean 1 in 1,000 or 1 in 100,000. Ask for the specific numbers.
    • Example: “When you say ‘rare,’ could you give me a more specific number? Is that 1 in 100, 1 in 1,000, or something else?”
  • Understand Timeframes: When will the benefits or side effects likely appear? How long does treatment typically last?
    • Example: “If I start this medication, how long before I can expect to see an improvement in my symptoms?” or “How long does the recovery typically take for this procedure?”
  • Discuss Variability: Acknowledge that individual results can vary.
    • Example: “While you’ve given me averages, what factors might make my outcome different, either better or worse?”

6. Collaboratively Develop a Concrete Plan (Plan)

Once options are explored, preferences are voiced, and probabilities are understood, it’s time to co-create a clear, actionable plan.

Actionable Steps:

  • Summarize the Chosen Option: Reiterate the decision made to ensure both you and your clinician are on the same page.
    • Example: “So, we’ve decided to proceed with the lower-dose medication, and I’ll start taking it daily, with a follow-up appointment in six weeks to review its effectiveness.”
  • Define Next Steps Clearly: Who does what, and by when?
    • Example: “My next step is to schedule the MRI, and then we’ll meet again to discuss the results and finalize the surgical plan. You’ll send the referral to the imaging center by tomorrow.”
  • Write Down the Plan: Don’t rely solely on memory. Ask for a printout or write down the key elements yourself.
    • Example: “Could you please give me a summary of our discussion and the agreed-upon plan in writing? Or, ‘I’m just going to jot down the key points: Medication X, 5mg, once daily, re-evaluation in 6 weeks. Any side effects, call immediately.'”
  • Clarify Prescriptions and Referrals: Ensure you understand how to obtain medications or schedule referrals.
    • Example: “Will the prescription be sent electronically, or do I need a paper copy? What’s the process for booking the specialist appointment?”
  • Emergency Contact/What to Do If…: Understand when and how to seek help if your condition worsens or you experience unexpected side effects.
    • Example: “If I experience severe dizziness or shortness of breath after starting this medication, should I go to the emergency room, or call your office line?”

7. Establish a Protocol for Change and Review (Protocol for Change/Review)

Decisions aren’t always set in stone. Health conditions can evolve, and your preferences might change. Discussing how to revisit decisions is crucial for long-term care.

Actionable Steps:

  • Schedule Follow-Up: Clearly establish when and how you’ll re-evaluate the decision.
    • Example: “Let’s schedule a follow-up in three months to reassess your pain levels and the effectiveness of the physical therapy. If things aren’t improving, we can then discuss surgical options.”
  • Criteria for Changing Course: What symptoms or changes would trigger a need to adjust the plan?
    • Example: “If my blood sugar levels aren’t within the target range by our next visit, or if I experience significant weight gain, we’ll need to consider adjusting the insulin dosage.”
  • How to Initiate a Review: Understand the process if you feel the need to change the plan between scheduled appointments.
    • Example: “If my symptoms worsen significantly before our next appointment, should I call your office, or is there an urgent care line I should use?”
  • Understanding “Shared Responsibility” for Monitoring: For chronic conditions, discuss how you will monitor your own health and communicate changes.
    • Example: “I’ll keep a log of my blood pressure readings at home. How often should I send those to you, and at what point should I be concerned enough to call?”

8. Assess Your Confidence (Confidence)

Before leaving the consultation, take a moment to reflect on your level of comfort and certainty with the chosen path. This is a crucial, often overlooked, step.

Actionable Steps:

  • “Teach Back” Method: Explain the decision and the plan in your own words to your clinician. This confirms your understanding and identifies any misunderstandings.
    • Example: “Just so I’m clear, we’ve decided on Option B. That means I’ll take this pill twice a day, and if I have any stomach upset, I should try taking it with food. We’ll reassess in four weeks. Is that right?”
  • Rate Your Confidence: Use a simple scale (e.g., 1-10) to express your comfort level with the decision.
    • Example: “On a scale of 1 to 10, with 10 being completely confident, how confident do you feel about this plan?” If your score is low, discuss why. “I’m about a 6 right now, mainly because I’m still a little unclear on the recovery time for this procedure.”
  • Address Lingering Doubts: Don’t hesitate to voice any remaining uncertainties or questions, no matter how small they seem.
    • Example: “I think I understand everything, but I’m still a bit worried about managing the side effects while working. Can we talk about strategies for that?”
  • Acknowledge Agreement (or Disagreement): Conclude by affirming your agreement with the plan or respectfully stating if you need more time or information.
    • Example: “Thank you, Dr. [Clinician’s Name]. I feel much more confident about this approach now, and I’m ready to move forward.” or “I appreciate all the information. I’d like to take a day or two to process everything before making a final decision, if that’s okay.”

After the Consultation: Sustaining Shared Decision-Making

SDM isn’t a one-time event; it’s an ongoing process.

1. Review and Reflect on Your Plan

Take time to digest the information and the decision you’ve made.

Actionable Steps:

  • Review Your Notes: Go over what you wrote down or any materials provided by your clinician.

  • Discuss with Support System: Talk through the decision with your trusted family or friends. This can help solidify your understanding and address any lingering concerns.

  • Identify New Questions: As you reflect, new questions might arise. Note them down for your next interaction.

2. Communicate Changes and Concerns Proactively

Don’t wait for your next scheduled appointment if something changes or you have new concerns.

Actionable Steps:

  • Track Symptoms and Side Effects: Maintain a log of how you’re feeling, any new symptoms, or side effects from treatment.
    • Example: “On Day 3 of medication, I started experiencing mild headaches. By Day 5, they were moderate. Called the clinic on Day 6.”
  • Contact Your Healthcare Team: Reach out if you experience significant changes, unexpected side effects, or if you feel the plan isn’t working as expected.
    • Example: “My pain hasn’t decreased at all since starting the physical therapy sessions, and in fact, it feels a little worse. I’d like to discuss if we need to adjust the plan.”
  • Be Honest About Adherence: If you’re struggling to follow the plan (e.g., forgetting medication, finding lifestyle changes too difficult), be open and honest with your clinician. They can’t help you if they don’t know the full picture.
    • Example: “I’m finding it really hard to stick to the new diet because of my work schedule. Are there any alternative approaches we could consider that might be more manageable for me?”

3. Be an Advocate for Your Health

Shared decision-making empowers you, but it also requires you to be your own advocate.

Actionable Steps:

  • Persistence: If you don’t feel heard or understood, don’t give up. Seek clarification or a second opinion if necessary.

  • Self-Efficacy: Believe in your ability to manage your health and participate meaningfully in decisions.

  • Educate Yourself Continuously: Healthcare is always evolving. Stay updated on your condition and relevant advancements from reliable sources.

Overcoming Challenges in Shared Decision-Making

While the ideal SDM process is collaborative, real-world situations can present challenges.

1. Time Constraints

Clinicians often have limited time with each patient.

Solutions:

  • Be Prepared: Having your questions prioritized and information ready saves valuable time.

  • Be Concise: Articulate your points clearly and succinctly.

  • Ask for a Follow-Up: If you can’t cover everything, ask for a separate appointment to delve deeper or continue the discussion. “I have a few more questions about the long-term implications; could we schedule a brief follow-up call or appointment to discuss those?”

2. Information Overload or Underload

Some clinicians might provide too much complex information, others too little.

Solutions:

  • Request Simplicity: “Could you explain that in simpler terms?” or “Can you break that down into smaller pieces for me?”

  • Ask for More Detail: “Could you elaborate on what you mean by ‘cardiac event risk’?” or “Do you have any written materials that explain this in more detail?”

  • Utilize “Teach Back”: This reveals if you’ve truly grasped the information.

3. Discrepancies in Beliefs or Values

Your preferences might not align with your clinician’s initial recommendations.

Solutions:

  • Open and Honest Dialogue: Explain your values and why certain options are more appealing (or less appealing) to you.

  • Focus on Common Ground: Look for solutions that address both clinical needs and your personal priorities.

  • Seek Compromise: There might be a middle ground. “I understand you recommend Option A, but given my preference for avoiding surgery, could we first try an extended period of intensive physical therapy and re-evaluate?”

  • Second Opinion: If fundamental disagreements persist, a second opinion can provide additional perspectives and potentially new options.

4. Fear or Anxiety

Dealing with health issues can be emotionally challenging, impacting your ability to engage.

Solutions:

  • Acknowledge Your Feelings: It’s okay to tell your clinician you’re feeling anxious or overwhelmed. “I’m finding this a bit overwhelming to process right now.”

  • Take Breaks: If the discussion becomes too intense, ask for a brief pause.

  • Bring a Support Person: Their presence can provide comfort and help you stay focused.

The Powerful Impact of Shared Decision-Making

Engaging in SDM isn’t just about making a single choice; it’s about fostering a long-term, trusting relationship with your healthcare team. When you actively participate, you:

  • Gain a Deeper Understanding: You truly grasp your condition and treatment options.

  • Make Better Decisions: Decisions are more aligned with your personal values and lifestyle.

  • Improve Treatment Adherence: You’re more likely to stick to a plan you helped create.

  • Experience Greater Satisfaction: You feel more in control and satisfied with your care.

  • Achieve Better Health Outcomes: Research consistently shows that SDM leads to improved health outcomes for many conditions.

By implementing the actionable strategies outlined in this guide, and by embracing the P7C framework, you can transform your healthcare experience. You are not merely a patient; you are an essential partner in your own health journey. Your voice, your values, and your preferences are invaluable. Take the reins, engage actively, and empower yourself to make truly informed decisions about your health.