How to Compare Health Share Plans

by

The landscape of healthcare options can feel like a labyrinth, with traditional health insurance often being the most familiar, yet sometimes inaccessible or unaffordable path. Enter health share plans – a growing alternative that has garnered significant attention for its community-based approach to medical cost sharing. But how do you navigate this alternative? How do you compare health share plans effectively to ensure you’re making a truly informed decision for your health and financial well-being? This definitive guide will cut through the noise, providing a meticulous, actionable framework for comparing health share plans, ensuring you understand every nuanced detail.

The Foundation: Understanding What Health Share Plans Are (and Aren’t)

Before diving into comparisons, it’s crucial to grasp the fundamental nature of health share plans. Unlike traditional health insurance, which is a contractual agreement between an individual and an insurer guaranteeing coverage for specified services in exchange for premiums, health share plans are membership-based programs where individuals with shared beliefs (often religious or ethical) voluntarily pool their resources to help cover each other’s medical expenses.

Key Distinctions to Remember:

  • Not Insurance: Health share plans are not health insurance. They are generally exempt from the regulations governing traditional insurance, including the Affordable Care Act (ACA) mandates. This means they don’t necessarily have to cover the 10 essential health benefits or adhere to guaranteed issue requirements.

  • Community-Based: The core principle is mutual aid and shared responsibility. Members contribute a monthly “share” amount, which is then used to pay for eligible medical needs of other members.

  • Voluntary: Participation is voluntary, and the “sharing” of medical costs is based on the community’s collective agreement and ability to contribute. There’s no legal guarantee of payment like there is with an insurance policy.

  • Belief System Alignment: Many, though not all, health share ministries are faith-based, requiring members to adhere to specific religious or ethical guidelines. This can influence what medical services are considered eligible for sharing.

Understanding these foundational differences is your first critical step. If you’re seeking the legal guarantees and comprehensive regulatory oversight of traditional insurance, a health share plan might not be the right fit. However, for those seeking a potentially more affordable alternative aligned with their values, and who understand the inherent differences, health share plans offer a compelling option.

Deconstructing the Comparison: Essential Factors to Evaluate

Comparing health share plans requires a methodical approach, looking beyond the monthly contribution amount. You need to meticulously examine their guidelines, benefits, limitations, and operational procedures.

1. Statement of Beliefs and Eligibility Requirements

This is arguably the most fundamental aspect to consider, especially for faith-based health share ministries. Each organization will have a “Statement of Beliefs” or a set of guidelines that members are expected to adhere to.

Actionable Steps:

  • Read the Statement of Beliefs Thoroughly: Do your personal beliefs and lifestyle choices align with the organization’s requirements? For example, many Christian health share plans require members to abstain from tobacco and illegal drugs, and some may have specific stances on alcohol consumption or premarital sexual activity. Some may also require regular church attendance.

  • Assess Lifestyle Requirements: Beyond religious tenets, some plans emphasize healthy living. Understand if there are any specific behavioral expectations (e.g., maintaining a certain BMI, participating in wellness programs).

  • Check Membership Criteria: Are there age limits, residency requirements, or any other demographic restrictions? Some plans cater specifically to families, singles, or seniors.

  • Example: Imagine “Compassionate Care Share,” a hypothetical Christian health share. Their statement of beliefs explicitly requires members to affirm a specific Christian creed, avoid tobacco and excessive alcohol, and be married or celibate. If you don’t align with these specific tenets, this plan, regardless of its financial benefits, wouldn’t be suitable for you. Conversely, “Harmony Health Collective” might be non-denominational, focusing solely on a general commitment to healthy living and community support, which might appeal to a broader audience.

2. Member Responsibility Amounts (MRA) / Annual Household Portion (AHP) / Initial Unshareable Amount (IUA)

These are the health share equivalents of an insurance deductible. It’s the amount you, as a member, are responsible for paying out-of-pocket for eligible medical expenses before the community begins to share costs.

Actionable Steps:

  • Understand the Amount: How much is the MRA/AHP/IUA? These can range significantly, from a few hundred dollars to several thousand.

  • Individual vs. Family Limits: Is the MRA per individual, or is there a family maximum? A plan with a $2,500 individual MRA might cap at $7,500 for a family of three or more, meaning once three family members each meet their $2,500 MRA, the family has hit its maximum for the year.

  • Impact on Monthly Share: Generally, a higher MRA/AHP/IUA will correspond to a lower monthly share amount, and vice-versa. Decide on a balance that suits your budget and risk tolerance.

  • Concrete Example: Plan A has a $1,000 MRA per person, capped at $3,000 per family. Plan B has a $5,000 AHP per family, regardless of the number of individuals. If you’re a family of five and anticipate minimal medical needs, Plan B might offer a lower overall monthly cost. However, if one family member has a significant medical event, you’ll be responsible for the first $5,000 with Plan B, whereas with Plan A, if only one person incurs expenses, your maximum out-of-pocket before sharing starts is $1,000.

3. Sharing Limits: Annual and Lifetime Maximums

Unlike traditional insurance plans which, thanks to the ACA, generally cannot impose lifetime or annual dollar limits on essential health benefits, many health share plans do have these limits.

Actionable Steps:

  • Identify Sharing Caps: What is the maximum amount the community will share for your medical expenses within a year? What about over your lifetime?

  • Assess Against Potential Needs: If you anticipate potentially high medical costs due to a chronic condition, a plan with lower sharing limits could leave you with substantial out-of-pocket expenses.

  • Consider Catastrophic Coverage: Many health share plans are designed primarily for catastrophic events. Ensure the annual and lifetime limits align with your comfort level for high-cost medical scenarios.

  • Example: “Unity Share” has an annual sharing limit of $250,000 per member and a lifetime limit of $1 million. “Community Care Collective” has no annual limit but a $500,000 lifetime limit per member. If you face a severe, long-term illness requiring extensive, ongoing treatment that could exceed $500,000, Unity Share’s higher lifetime limit might offer more security.

4. Covered Services and Exclusions

This is where the flexibility of health share plans becomes apparent, but also where careful scrutiny is paramount. What one plan considers “shareable,” another might explicitly exclude.

Actionable Steps:

  • Review the Sharing Guidelines Document: This is the most critical document. It explicitly lists what types of medical needs are eligible for sharing and what are not. Don’t rely on summaries or anecdotal information.

  • Common Exclusions: Be aware of common exclusions, which can include:

    • Pre-existing Conditions: Most health share plans have waiting periods (e.g., 12-24 months, sometimes longer) before expenses related to pre-existing conditions become shareable, if at all. Some may never share for certain pre-existing conditions.

    • Preventive Care: Some plans may not share for routine preventive services like annual physicals, screenings, or vaccinations. Others might offer limited preventive sharing or discounts.

    • Maternity Care: While many plans do share for maternity, there might be specific requirements (e.g., must be married, waiting periods for conception).

    • Mental Health/Substance Abuse: Coverage for these can be very limited or non-existent in some plans.

    • Prescription Drugs: Often, only inpatient or acute prescriptions are shareable. Many plans rely on discount programs for routine medications rather than direct sharing.

    • Elective Procedures: Cosmetic surgery, fertility treatments, and other elective procedures are typically not shareable.

  • Specific Needs Assessment: Make a list of your anticipated healthcare needs. Do you have a chronic condition? Are you planning a family? Do you rely on specific prescription medications? Cross-reference these needs with the plan’s sharing guidelines.

  • Example: You have mild asthma that requires daily medication. Plan X states a 12-month waiting period for pre-existing conditions, after which asthma-related needs (including medication) become 80% shareable. Plan Y, however, permanently excludes pre-existing conditions. For your asthma, Plan X is clearly the better choice. If you’re generally healthy and rarely see a doctor, the lack of extensive preventive care sharing might not be a deal-breaker.

5. Waiting Periods

Beyond pre-existing conditions, health share plans can have waiting periods for various services.

Actionable Steps:

  • Understand All Waiting Periods: Are there waiting periods for major surgeries, specific conditions (like cancer), or even maternity?

  • Impact on Immediate Needs: If you anticipate a need in the near future, a waiting period could mean significant out-of-pocket expenses for which you wouldn’t receive sharing.

  • Example: You are considering a knee replacement within the next six months. Plan A has a 24-month waiting period for orthopedic surgeries. Plan B has no specific waiting period for surgeries beyond the initial membership period (e.g., 30 days). Clearly, Plan B is more favorable if your surgery timeline is firm.

6. Provider Networks and Choice

Unlike traditional insurance, which often heavily emphasizes in-network providers, many health share plans offer more flexibility.

Actionable Steps:

  • Open Network vs. Preferred Provider Lists: Some health share plans operate on an “open network” model, allowing you to see any licensed provider, with the understanding that you negotiate cash prices. Others may have preferred provider lists or discount networks that offer reduced rates.

  • “Self-Pay” Patient Approach: Many health share plans encourage members to present themselves as “self-pay” patients to providers. This often allows for significant discounts on services, as providers avoid the administrative burden and lower reimbursement rates associated with insurance billing. Understand how this process works.

  • Bill Negotiation Services: Does the health share plan offer bill negotiation services to help you get lower prices on medical bills? This can be a significant benefit.

  • Doctor Preference: Do you have specific doctors or specialists you want to continue seeing? Verify if the health share plan’s model accommodates this.

  • Example: You have a long-standing relationship with a particular specialist. Health Share Z promotes a “direct pay” model where you pay the provider upfront and then submit for sharing, allowing you to choose any doctor. Health Share W has a limited network of “preferred providers” and heavily incentivizes using them. If maintaining your current doctor is paramount, Health Share Z aligns better with your needs.

7. Monthly Share Amounts and Administrative Fees

The “premium” equivalent in a health share plan is your monthly share. However, also look out for additional fees.

Actionable Steps:

  • Compare Monthly Contributions: Get quotes for your household size and age group from several plans.

  • Look for Hidden Fees: Are there application fees, annual renewal fees, or other administrative charges?

  • Impact of Age and Family Size: How do these factors influence your monthly contribution? Most plans tier their shares based on age and household size.

  • Stability of Shares: While not guaranteed, inquire about the historical stability of monthly share amounts. Have they significantly increased year over year?

  • Example: Plan R has a monthly share of $300 for a family of four, with a $100 application fee and a $50 annual renewal. Plan S has a monthly share of $320 for the same family, with no application or renewal fees. Over several years, the seemingly cheaper Plan R might end up being more expensive due to recurring fees.

8. The Sharing Process: How Funds are Disbursed

Understanding how claims are processed and how you receive funds is crucial.

Actionable Steps:

  • Reimbursement vs. Direct Pay: Do you pay the provider first and then get reimbursed by the health share, or does the health share pay the provider directly? Most health share plans operate on a reimbursement model.

  • Timeline for Reimbursement: How long does it typically take for a medical need to be processed and funds to be disbursed? Delays can impact your ability to pay large bills.

  • Documentation Requirements: What documentation is needed to submit a medical need for sharing? Is the process cumbersome or streamlined?

  • Member Support: Is there a dedicated team to assist with understanding bills and submitting needs?

  • Example: You have a hospital bill for $10,000 after your MRA. Plan X states a typical reimbursement time of 60-90 days, requiring you to pay the hospital upfront. Plan Y boasts a 14-day reimbursement period for all approved needs. If immediate reimbursement is critical for your financial situation, Plan Y offers a clear advantage.

9. Member Community and Support

Beyond the financial aspect, the community and support elements are often highlighted as a key benefit of health share plans.

Actionable Steps:

  • Community Engagement: How does the organization foster community among its members? Are there opportunities for prayer, encouragement, or other forms of mutual support?

  • Telehealth/Wellness Programs: Do they offer additional perks like telemedicine, health coaching, or discounts on wellness products? These can add significant value.

  • Member Reviews/Testimonials: While taking them with a grain of salt, look for reviews or testimonials from current members to gauge their satisfaction with the organization’s responsiveness and support.

  • Example: Plan Alpha emphasizes a robust online community forum where members can share prayer requests and offer encouragement, alongside a free telehealth service. Plan Beta focuses purely on cost sharing with minimal community interaction. If the spiritual and communal aspect is important to you, Plan Alpha might be a better fit.

10. Financial Stability and Transparency

While not regulated like insurance companies, it’s still important to consider the financial health of the organization.

Actionable Steps:

  • Independent Audits: Does the organization undergo independent audits, and are these reports available? This indicates a commitment to transparency.

  • Years in Operation: How long has the health share organization been in operation? A longer track record can suggest greater stability.

  • Member Growth: Is the organization growing? Sustainable growth can indicate a healthy membership base to support sharing.

  • Regulatory Status: While not insurance, confirm their legal status and exemption from insurance regulations in your state.

  • Example: During your research, you find that “Evergreen Health Share” publishes annual financial reports audited by a reputable third-party firm, showing consistent growth over the past decade. “New Horizon Share,” however, has only been operating for two years and offers no publicly available financial information. Evergreen, in this scenario, presents a more reassuring picture of financial stability.

A Practical Comparison Scenario

Let’s imagine the Johnson family – John (45), Sarah (42), and their two children (10 and 7). They are healthy, active, and looking for an alternative to their expensive traditional health insurance. They are active in their church and align with Christian values.

They are comparing two hypothetical Christian health share plans: Covenant HealthShare and Faith & Family Share.

Feature

Covenant HealthShare

Faith & Family Share

Statement of Beliefs

Strict Christian tenets, abstinence from tobacco/alcohol/illicit drugs, regular church attendance encouraged.

General Christian principles, healthy lifestyle emphasized, no specific church attendance requirement.

Monthly Share

$450/month (Family of 4, Ages 40-49)

$480/month (Family of 4, Ages 40-49)

Annual Household Portion (AHP)

$5,000 per family, no individual MRA.

$2,500 per person, capped at $7,500 per family.

Annual Sharing Limit

$500,000 per member per year

No annual limit

Lifetime Sharing Limit

$2 Million per member

$1 Million per member

Pre-existing Conditions

24-month waiting period, then 50% share for 1st year, 75% for 2nd, 100% after 48 months.

12-month waiting period, then 100% share for 3 years, then full. Certain conditions (e.g., cancer) may have longer waits.

Preventive Care

Not shared, but discounts available via network.

$150 annual allowance per member for preventive.

Maternity

Shareable after 12-month membership.

Shareable after 9-month membership, if conception occurs after joining.

Prescription Drugs

Acute prescriptions shared for 30 days. Discount card for ongoing meds.

Discount card only.

Provider Network

Open network, encourages cash payment/negotiation.

Preferred provider network with some out-of-network sharing (higher AHP).

Reimbursement Time

Average 45-60 days

Average 30-45 days

Additional Fees

$75 application fee

$50 annual renewal fee

Added Benefits

Telemedicine ($0 co-share), health coaching.

Bill negotiation service, wellness webinars.

Analysis for the Johnson Family:

  • Beliefs: Both align with their Christian values. Covenant is stricter, but F&F is still acceptable.

  • Cost: Covenant is slightly cheaper monthly, but F&F has a lower annual renewal fee. The total annual cost difference isn’t huge initially.

  • AHP: This is a key differentiator. Covenant has a $5,000 family AHP. If only one child breaks an arm, they’d need to meet that $5,000 before sharing. F&F’s $2,500 per person ($7,500 family cap) means if only one child needs extensive care, they’d only be responsible for $2,500. This is a significant factor for families where individual incidents are more likely than multiple high-cost events simultaneously.

  • Sharing Limits: Covenant offers higher annual and lifetime limits, which is appealing for potential catastrophic events.

  • Pre-existing Conditions: Neither John nor Sarah has major pre-existing conditions, but if either did, Covenant’s longer full sharing period (48 months vs. 3 years for F&F) would be a consideration.

  • Preventive Care: F&F’s $150 annual allowance per member for preventive care is a clear advantage over Covenant, which only offers discounts. For a family of four, this could mean $600 in shared preventive care.

  • Maternity: Not currently applicable, but if they planned more children, F&F’s shorter waiting period would be a plus.

  • Prescriptions: Both rely heavily on discount cards for ongoing medications, which is common.

  • Provider Choice: Both offer good flexibility, with F&F having a preferred network, which could simplify some billing.

  • Reimbursement: F&F’s faster reimbursement time (30-45 days vs. 45-60 days) is a practical benefit.

Decision Point:

For the Johnson family, the $2,500 per-person AHP with a family cap in Faith & Family Share, combined with the annual preventive care allowance and faster reimbursement, likely outweighs Covenant’s slightly lower monthly share and higher catastrophic limits. While Covenant offers more catastrophic protection, the more flexible AHP and tangible preventive care benefits of Faith & Family Share better align with their current family needs and budget for routine care. They value the lower individual MRA for minor-to-moderate needs more than the extremely high catastrophic limit they hope never to reach.

The Powerful Conclusion: Empowering Your Healthcare Choice

Comparing health share plans is not a quick task; it’s a deep dive into an alternative healthcare model. It demands your diligence, your critical thinking, and a clear understanding of your own healthcare needs, financial situation, and personal beliefs. There’s no single “best” health share plan, just the best fit for you.

By systematically evaluating the statement of beliefs, member responsibility amounts, sharing limits, covered services, waiting periods, provider flexibility, costs, and operational transparency, you empower yourself to make a decision that supports your well-being. Look beyond the appealing monthly contribution and truly dissect the sharing guidelines. Engage with the organizations, ask probing questions, and understand the nuances. With this comprehensive guide, you possess the tools to navigate the health share landscape confidently, choosing a plan that aligns not just with your budget, but with your values and your vision for a secure healthcare future.