How to Evaluate Medical Claims

by

Evaluating medical claims is a critical skill for anyone navigating the complex world of healthcare. Whether you’re a patient, a healthcare provider, or an administrative professional, understanding how to meticulously review and validate these claims can prevent significant financial discrepancies, ensure appropriate care, and safeguard against fraudulent practices. This guide strips away the jargon and provides a direct, actionable framework for evaluating medical claims, empowering you to identify errors, challenge discrepancies, and secure fair treatment within the healthcare system.

The Foundation: Understanding the Medical Claims Lifecycle

Before diving into evaluation, it’s essential to grasp the journey a medical claim undertakes. This lifecycle isn’t just a linear process; it involves multiple touchpoints and distinct stages where errors can creep in.

  1. Patient Registration & Information Collection: This is where the patient’s demographic details, insurance information, and medical history are first recorded. Accuracy here is paramount.

  2. Service Delivery & Documentation: Healthcare providers render services, and every interaction, diagnosis, procedure, and prescription is meticulously documented in the patient’s medical record.

  3. Medical Coding: Clinical documentation is translated into standardized alphanumeric codes (ICD-10 for diagnoses, CPT for procedures, HCPCS for supplies/services not covered by CPT). This is a specialized process crucial for clear communication between providers and payers.

  4. Claim Creation & Submission: The coded information is compiled into a formal claim, often an electronic data interchange (EDI) format like the CMS-1500 or UB-04, and submitted to the insurance payer.

  5. Claim Adjudication (Insurance Review): The insurance company processes the claim, verifying eligibility, medical necessity, policy coverage, and applying network rates, deductibles, and co-pays.

  6. Payment or Denial: The insurer either pays the provider (and/or patient) or denies the claim, providing a reason for the denial.

  7. Patient Billing: The patient receives an Explanation of Benefits (EOB) from their insurer and a bill from the provider for any remaining balance.

  8. Appeals Process: If a claim is denied or paid incorrectly, the patient or provider can appeal the decision.

Each stage presents opportunities for errors, making a systematic evaluation process indispensable.

Step 1: Gather All Relevant Documents – Your Essential Toolkit

Before you can evaluate a medical claim, you need all the pieces of the puzzle. Missing even one document can lead to an incomplete or inaccurate assessment.

1.1 The Medical Bill (Provider’s Statement)

This is the invoice from the healthcare provider or facility.

Actionable Insight: Request an itemized bill. A summary bill might show a single large charge, but an itemized bill breaks down every service, supply, and medication with its individual cost and corresponding date.

Example: Instead of seeing “Hospital Stay: $15,000,” an itemized bill would list:

  • “Room and Board, Semi-Private, 3 days: $3,000”

  • “Lab Test (Complete Blood Count), 07/20/2025: $150”

  • “Medication (Pain Reliever, dosage), 07/20/2025: $50”

  • “IV Fluids, 07/21/2025: $100”

  • “Consultation, Dr. Smith, Cardiology, 07/21/2025: $400”

1.2 Explanation of Benefits (EOB) from Your Insurer

The EOB is not a bill, but a statement from your health insurance company explaining what services were covered, how much was paid, and what your responsibility is.

Actionable Insight: Always compare the EOB directly with the itemized medical bill. They should align in terms of services, dates, and amounts.

Example: Your EOB for the hospital stay might show:

  • “Total Billed Amount: $15,000”

  • “Negotiated Rate/Allowed Amount: $10,000”

  • “Applied to Deductible: $1,000”

  • “Coinsurance (20% of remaining $9,000): $1,800”

  • “Plan Paid: $7,200”

  • “Your Responsibility: $2,800” (Deductible + Coinsurance)

1.3 Your Health Insurance Policy Document

This document, often lengthy, outlines the specifics of your coverage, including deductibles, co-pays, coinsurance percentages, in-network vs. out-of-network benefits, pre-authorization requirements, and exclusions.

Actionable Insight: Highlight key sections related to your current claim: annual deductible, out-of-pocket maximum, specific coverage for the type of service received (e.g., surgery, physical therapy, mental health), and any pre-authorization rules.

Example: If your policy states “Physical Therapy: 80% coverage after deductible, maximum 20 sessions per calendar year,” you’ll use this to verify if the billed physical therapy sessions fall within these limits and if the coinsurance calculation is correct.

1.4 Your Medical Records

These are the notes from your doctor, nurses, and other healthcare professionals detailing your diagnosis, treatment plan, procedures performed, medications administered, and all relevant clinical observations.

Actionable Insight: Request a copy of your full medical records related to the dates of service on the claim. This is crucial for verifying medical necessity and accuracy of coding.

Example: If a lab test for “XYZ marker” appears on your bill, your medical records should contain a doctor’s order for that specific test and a clinical justification for why it was needed. If it’s absent or the justification is weak, it raises a red flag.

1.5 Records of Communication

Maintain a log of all phone calls, emails, and written correspondence with your provider’s billing office and your insurance company. Include dates, times, names of representatives, and a summary of the discussion.

Actionable Insight: This log provides a concrete timeline and evidence of your efforts if a dispute escalates.

Example: “July 15, 2025, 10:30 AM: Called ABC Insurance, spoke with Sarah (Rep ID 12345). Discussed denied claim for MRI. Sarah stated denial due to ‘lack of pre-authorization.’ I explained pre-authorization was obtained on June 10, 2025 (Auth #67890). Sarah noted this and said she would re-review the claim.”

Step 2: Systematically Review the Claim for Accuracy

Once you have your documents, begin a methodical review. This is where most errors are uncovered.

2.1 Verify Personal and Insurance Information

Even small typographical errors here can cause major processing delays or denials.

Actionable Insight: Cross-reference your name, date of birth, insurance ID number, group number, and policy effective dates on every document (bill, EOB, policy).

Example: If your insurance ID on the bill is “ABC12345” but your card shows “ABC12346,” that’s an immediate flag. Correcting this simple error can prevent a full claim denial.

2.2 Validate Dates of Service

Ensure the dates on the bill precisely match the dates you received services.

Actionable Insight: Compare the “Date of Service” on your itemized bill and EOB with your personal calendar or memory.

Example: If your bill lists a physical therapy session on July 1st, 2025, but you were on vacation that day, it’s an error. Similarly, if you were discharged from the hospital on July 5th but billed for an extra day, challenge it.

2.3 Scrutinize Service Descriptions and Codes

This is often the most complex part of the evaluation, as it involves understanding medical coding.

2.3.1 Understand Common Medical Code Sets

  • CPT (Current Procedural Terminology) Codes: Five-digit numeric codes for medical, surgical, and diagnostic services (e.g., 99213 for an established patient office visit, 93000 for an ECG).

  • HCPCS (Healthcare Common Procedure Coding System) Level II Codes: Alphanumeric codes for products, supplies, and services not covered by CPT (e.g., durable medical equipment, ambulance services, certain medications).

  • ICD-10-CM (International Classification of Diseases, Tenth Revision, Clinical Modification) Codes: Alphanumeric codes for diagnoses and symptoms (e.g., I10 for Essential Hypertension, J02.9 for Acute Pharyngitis, Unspecified).

Actionable Insight: Use online resources (often available through professional coding organizations or insurance payer websites) to look up unfamiliar codes. If the description on the bill is vague, use the code to get a precise understanding.

Example: Your bill might say “Office Visit.” Looking up CPT code “99214” reveals it’s for an established patient visit with moderate complexity. Does that align with the complexity of your actual visit?

2.3.2 Match Services to Medical Records

Every service billed should have a corresponding entry and justification in your medical records.

Actionable Insight: Line by line, compare the services and their associated codes on the itemized bill with the documentation in your medical records.

Example: If a bill shows a “Blood Culture” (CPT code 87040) but your medical record shows no order for a blood culture, or the result is missing, question it. Similarly, if your doctor’s notes indicate a follow-up for a common cold, but the diagnosis code used (ICD-10) is for a complex chronic illness, this could be “upcoding” – billing for a more expensive service than performed.

2.3.3 Identify Duplicate Billing

This is a common error where the same service is billed multiple times.

Actionable Insight: Look for identical service codes and dates. If you see two charges for the same lab test on the same day, or two charges for “Room and Board” for a single night’s stay, it’s likely a duplicate.

Example: Your bill shows “X-ray Chest, 07/22/2025: $200” twice. Unless two distinct chest X-rays were performed, this is a duplicate.

2.3.4 Spot “Unbundling”

Unbundling occurs when services that are typically grouped under one comprehensive code are billed separately to inflate the cost.

Actionable Insight: This is harder to detect without coding knowledge, but if you see many small, seemingly related charges instead of one larger, comprehensive one for a procedure, it’s worth investigating.

Example: Instead of billing a single CPT code for a comprehensive surgical procedure that includes anesthesia and post-operative care, a provider might bill for the surgery, anesthesia, and post-op visits separately when they should be bundled.

2.3.5 Check for Services Not Rendered

This is a serious issue that could be accidental or fraudulent.

Actionable Insight: If you see a charge for a procedure, medication, or test that you definitively did not receive, challenge it immediately.

Example: Your bill includes a charge for “Physical Therapy, Modality – Ultrasound, 07/23/2025,” but you distinctly remember only doing exercises with the therapist that day, with no ultrasound equipment used.

2.4 Evaluate Medical Necessity

Insurance companies pay for services that are “medically necessary.” This is often a subjective area, but critical.

Actionable Insight: Your medical records should clearly justify why a particular service was needed. Look for alignment between the diagnosis (ICD-10) and the procedure/treatment (CPT/HCPCS).

Example: If your diagnosis is “common cold” (J00), but the bill includes an MRI of the brain, the medical necessity of the MRI would be highly questionable and likely denied. The provider’s notes should explain the medical rationale linking your symptoms to the need for that specific diagnostic test.

2.5 Compare Billed Amounts to Negotiated Rates and Your Policy

This step helps you understand your financial responsibility.

Actionable Insight:

  • Total Billed Amount: The gross amount the provider charged.

  • Allowed Amount/Negotiated Rate: The maximum amount your insurance company will pay for a covered service, based on their contract with the provider.

  • Plan Paid: The amount your insurance company actually paid.

  • Applied to Deductible: The portion of the allowed amount that counts towards your annual deductible.

  • Coinsurance/Copay: Your percentage share of the cost (coinsurance) or a fixed amount (copay).

  • Patient Responsibility/Balance Due: The amount you owe.

Ensure these figures on your EOB are correctly calculated based on your policy’s terms.

Example: If your policy states a $1,000 deductible and 20% coinsurance after the deductible, and your EOB for a $5,000 “allowed amount” shows you owe $2,000, verify the math:

  • $1,000 (deductible) + (20% of ($5,000 – $1,000 deductible)) = $1,000 + (20% of $4,000) = $1,000 + $800 = $1,800. If the EOB states $2,000, there’s a $200 discrepancy to investigate.

Step 3: Identify Potential Errors and Discrepancies

As you conduct your systematic review, actively list any potential errors you find. Categorizing them helps in formulating your approach.

3.1 Coding Errors

  • Upcoding: Billing for a more complex or expensive service than was actually provided.
    • Example: Billing for a comprehensive office visit (CPT 99215) when only a brief, follow-up visit (CPT 99212) occurred.
  • Downcoding: Billing for a less complex or expensive service than was actually provided (less common for patient disputes, but can impact provider reimbursement).

  • Incorrect Code Usage: Using a code that doesn’t accurately reflect the service or diagnosis.

    • Example: Billing a diagnostic mammogram (indicating symptoms) when a screening mammogram (preventive) was performed, as coverage for these can differ.
  • Missing Modifiers: Modifiers are two-digit codes added to CPT/HCPCS codes to provide additional information (e.g., bilateral procedure, professional component only). Missing or incorrect modifiers can lead to denials.
    • Example: A surgeon performs a bilateral knee scope, but the CPT code for the scope is only listed once without the “-50” modifier for bilateral procedures. This could lead to underpayment or denial.

3.2 Billing Errors

  • Duplicate Charges: Billing for the same service multiple times.

  • Services Not Rendered: Charges for procedures or items you never received.

  • Incorrect Patient or Insurance Information: Mismatched names, dates of birth, policy numbers, or group numbers.

  • Balance Billing (Out-of-Network): Being billed for the difference between the provider’s charge and your insurer’s allowed amount when using an out-of-network provider, unless it’s explicitly allowed by your plan or state law (e.g., in some emergency situations, the No Surprises Act protects against this).

    • Example: An out-of-network emergency room charges $1,000, your insurer allows $600, and you’re billed for the $400 difference. If protected by the No Surprises Act, you might only owe your in-network cost-sharing.

3.3 Coverage and Adjudication Errors

  • Incorrect Application of Deductible/Coinsurance/Copay: Your EOB shows calculations that don’t align with your policy.

  • Failure to Apply Negotiated Rates: The provider’s bill does not reflect the discount agreed upon with your insurance company (if they are in-network).

  • Denial for “Lack of Medical Necessity” without Clear Justification: Your insurer denies a claim, but your medical records clearly support the necessity of the service.

  • Denial for “Lack of Pre-authorization” when it was Obtained: Your insurer denies a claim citing a missing pre-authorization, but you have proof it was approved.

  • Coordination of Benefits (COB) Issues: If you have multiple insurance plans, errors can occur in determining which plan is primary and secondary.

Step 4: Take Action – The Resolution Phase

Finding errors is only the beginning. The next step is to actively resolve them.

4.1 Contact the Provider’s Billing Department First

Often, errors are administrative. Start with a polite, but firm, call to the provider’s billing department.

Actionable Insight:

  • Have all your documents ready (itemized bill, EOB, medical records).

  • Clearly state the specific discrepancy you’ve identified.

  • Reference specific dates, codes, and amounts.

  • Ask for a corrected bill or an adjustment to your account.

  • Document the call: date, time, representative’s name, and what was agreed upon.

Example: “Hello, I’m calling about account number [your account number] for services on [date]. I’ve received a bill for $X, but my EOB shows an allowed amount of $Y, and I believe the charge for CPT code [code] on [date] is incorrect because [reason: duplicate, not rendered, etc.]. Can you please review this and send a corrected bill?”

4.2 Engage Your Insurance Company

If the provider’s billing department is unhelpful or the issue stems from the insurance company’s adjudication, contact your insurer.

Actionable Insight:

  • Refer to your EOB and claim number.

  • Explain the discrepancy and provide supporting evidence from your medical bill or records.

  • If a claim was denied, ask for a detailed explanation and the specific reason code.

  • If the denial is due to “medical necessity,” explain how your medical records justify the service.

  • Document all communication.

Example: “My claim, ID [claim ID], for services on [date] was denied due to ‘lack of medical necessity.’ However, my medical records from Dr. [Doctor’s Name] clearly state [specific medical justification]. Can you please reopen this claim for re-adjudication based on this information?”

4.3 Initiate an Internal Appeal (If Denied or Unresolved)

If your initial calls don’t resolve the issue, you have the right to an internal appeal with your insurance company. This is a formal request for them to reconsider their decision.

Actionable Insight:

  • Understand the Deadline: You typically have 180 days (6 months) from the date of denial to file an internal appeal.

  • Submit in Writing: A written appeal provides a clear record. Use certified mail with a return receipt requested.

  • Be Comprehensive: Include a clear letter outlining the issue, why you believe the decision is incorrect, and all supporting documentation (itemized bill, EOB, relevant medical records, copies of previous correspondence/call logs).

  • State Your Desired Outcome: Do you want the claim paid in full? A portion paid? A re-evaluation?

  • Expedited Review: If your health or ability to function is at risk due to the denial (e.g., denial of urgent medication), request an expedited review.

Example (Letter Format): [Your Name] [Your Address] [Your Phone Number] [Your Email]

[Date]

[Insurance Company Name] Appeals Department [Insurance Company Address]

Subject: Internal Appeal – Claim ID: [Your Claim ID] – Date of Service: [Date(s) of Service]

Dear [Insurance Company Name] Appeals Department,

I am writing to formally appeal the denial of claim ID [Claim ID] for services rendered on [Date(s) of Service] by [Provider Name]. The reason for denial stated on the Explanation of Benefits (EOB) dated [Date of EOB] was “[Reason for Denial, e.g., Not Medically Necessary / Lack of Pre-authorization].”

I believe this denial is incorrect for the following reasons:

  1. [Specific Point 1 – e.g., Medical Necessity is Clear]: As detailed in the attached medical records from Dr. [Doctor’s Name] dated [Date], my condition of [Diagnosis] clearly necessitated the [Service/Procedure, CPT Code] for [Specific Justification from Records]. [Quote relevant sentences from medical records if possible].

  2. [Specific Point 2 – e.g., Pre-authorization was Obtained]: Pre-authorization for this service was obtained on [Date of Authorization] under authorization number [Authorization Number]. A copy of the authorization is attached.

  3. [Specific Point 3 – e.g., Coding Error]: The itemized bill (attached) shows CPT code [Incorrect Code] for [Service Description]. However, based on the services I received, I believe the correct code should be [Correct Code], which is covered under my plan.

I have attached the following supporting documents for your review:

  • Copy of Itemized Medical Bill from [Provider Name] for [Date(s) of Service]

  • Copy of Explanation of Benefits (EOB) for Claim ID [Claim ID]

  • Relevant Medical Records from [Provider Name] dated [Date Range]

  • Proof of Pre-authorization [if applicable]

  • My Health Insurance Policy Document (relevant pages highlighted)

I request a full and fair review of this claim and ask that it be re-adjudicated for payment according to my policy benefits. Please notify me of your decision within the timeframe mandated by law.

Sincerely,

[Your Signature] [Your Typed Name]

4.4 Pursue an External Review (If Internal Appeal Fails)

If your internal appeal is denied, you typically have the right to an independent external review. This means an independent third party, not affiliated with your insurer, will review your case.

Actionable Insight:

  • Deadlines are Crucial: Pay close attention to the deadline for requesting an external review after your internal appeal denial.

  • Follow Instructions Precisely: Your internal appeal denial letter should provide instructions on how to request an external review.

  • Submit All Documentation: Provide the external reviewer with all the same comprehensive documentation you used for your internal appeal, plus the internal appeal denial letter.

  • State Agencies: Contact your state’s Department of Insurance or equivalent regulatory agency for guidance and assistance with external reviews. They can often provide forms and specific procedures.

Example: If the external review board rules in your favor, your insurance company is legally obligated to overturn their denial and cover the claim.

Step 5: Advanced Strategies and Considerations

Beyond the core steps, these additional tips can enhance your claim evaluation process.

5.1 Understand Your Policy’s Nuances

  • Out-of-Pocket Maximum: Know your annual out-of-pocket maximum. Once you hit this, your insurer should cover 100% of covered services. Ensure all your payments (deductibles, co-pays, coinsurance) are counting towards this.

  • In-Network vs. Out-of-Network: Always confirm if a provider is in-network before receiving services, if possible. Out-of-network costs are typically much higher.

  • Referrals and Pre-authorizations: Some plans require referrals from a primary care physician for specialist visits or pre-authorization for certain procedures or medications. Failure to get these can lead to denials.

  • Formularies (for medications): Understand your plan’s drug formulary (list of covered medications) and tiers, as this affects your out-of-pocket costs for prescriptions.

5.2 Leverage Online Portals and Resources

Many insurance companies offer online portals where you can view claims status, EOBs, and even submit basic inquiries. Utilize these tools. Additionally, independent consumer advocacy groups and government health agencies often provide valuable guides and resources.

5.3 Don’t Be Afraid to Negotiate

Even after insurance, if you have a significant balance due, contact the provider’s billing department.

Actionable Insight:

  • Ask for a Discount: Many providers offer a discount for prompt payment, especially if you pay in full.

  • Payment Plans: Request a manageable payment plan.

  • Financial Assistance Programs: Hospitals often have financial assistance programs for low-income or uninsured patients. Inquire about these.

Example: “I understand my remaining balance is $2,500. While I’m working to verify the charges, this is still a significant amount for me. Do you offer any prompt-pay discounts, or could we set up a payment plan of $100 per month?”

5.4 Be Diligent with Record Keeping

Organization is your best friend throughout this process.

Actionable Insight:

  • Dedicated Folder/System: Create a dedicated physical or digital folder for all healthcare-related documents.

  • Chronological Order: Keep documents in chronological order.

  • Annotate: Make notes directly on bills or EOBs about dates of calls, representative names, and actions taken.

5.5 Understand Time Limits

Both providers and insurers have deadlines for submitting and processing claims, and you have deadlines for appeals. Be aware of these to avoid missing crucial windows.

Conclusion

Evaluating medical claims can feel like deciphering a foreign language, but by systematically applying the steps outlined in this guide, you gain control and confidence. Begin by gathering every pertinent document. Then, meticulously compare the information on your medical bills, EOBs, and personal medical records, focusing on patient details, dates of service, accurate coding, medical necessity, and financial calculations. When discrepancies emerge, initiate clear, documented communication with both the provider’s billing department and your insurance company. Should initial efforts prove insufficient, do not hesitate to pursue formal internal and, if necessary, external appeals. Through diligence, accurate record-keeping, and a proactive approach, you can effectively challenge errors, safeguard your financial well-being, and ensure you are only paying for the healthcare services you truly received and that were medically appropriate. This isn’t just about saving money; it’s about advocating for your health and ensuring transparency in a system designed to serve your well-being.