How to Discuss Birth Control with Your Doctor

by

In a world brimming with health information, navigating the topic of birth control can feel overwhelming. It’s a deeply personal decision, influenced by your health, lifestyle, future plans, and even your values. The key to making an informed choice lies in a candid, comprehensive discussion with your doctor. This isn’t just about getting a prescription; it’s about a partnership where you actively participate in your reproductive health journey. This guide will equip you with the knowledge, questions, and confidence to have that definitive conversation, ensuring you select a method that truly aligns with your needs.

The Foundation: Understanding Your “Why” for Birth Control

Before you even step into the doctor’s office, take time for introspection. Why are you considering birth control? This fundamental question will guide your discussion and help your doctor tailor recommendations. Your reasons might extend beyond simply preventing pregnancy.

Concrete Examples:

  • Pregnancy Prevention: This is the most common reason. Are you looking for short-term prevention, or a long-term solution? Do you anticipate wanting children in the distant future, or are you unsure?

  • Managing Menstrual Cycles: Many birth control methods can significantly alleviate symptoms like heavy bleeding, severe cramps, irregular periods, or even endometriosis pain. For instance, you might be struggling with debilitating period pain that interferes with your daily life, and you’re hoping birth control can offer relief.

  • Acne Management: Hormonal birth control can often improve hormonal acne by regulating hormone levels. Perhaps you’ve tried various skincare routines with limited success, and you’re exploring systemic solutions.

  • PCOS (Polycystic Ovary Syndrome) Management: Birth control can help regulate periods, reduce androgen-related symptoms like excessive hair growth, and protect the uterine lining in individuals with PCOS. You might have been diagnosed with PCOS and are seeking options to manage its diverse symptoms.

  • Migraine Relief: While some hormonal birth control can worsen certain types of migraines (especially those with aura), others can help stabilize hormone levels and reduce migraine frequency. It’s crucial to discuss your migraine history thoroughly.

  • Sexual Activity and Lifestyle: Do you have a single partner, multiple partners, or are you not currently sexually active but anticipating it? Your sexual activity patterns will influence the suitability of certain methods, particularly concerning STI protection.

By clearly articulating your primary and secondary reasons, you empower your doctor to consider the full spectrum of benefits a birth control method might offer, beyond just contraception.

Preparing for Your Appointment: The Power of Information

A well-prepared patient is an empowered patient. Gathering relevant information beforehand ensures a productive and efficient consultation.

Documenting Your Health History

Your medical history is paramount. Your doctor needs a complete picture to assess potential risks and recommend safe options.

Concrete Examples:

  • Pre-existing Medical Conditions:
    • Blood Clot History: Have you or a close family member ever had blood clots (DVT or pulmonary embolism)? This is critical, as certain hormonal birth control methods can increase the risk of blood clots.

    • High Blood Pressure: Are you diagnosed with hypertension? Uncontrolled high blood pressure can be a contraindication for combined hormonal methods.

    • Migraines with Aura: This specific type of migraine can increase the risk of stroke with combined hormonal contraceptives.

    • Heart Disease or Stroke: Any history of heart attack or stroke in you or your family is a significant factor.

    • Diabetes: Especially if it’s poorly controlled, diabetes can influence birth control choices.

    • Liver Disease or Cancer: These conditions can affect how your body processes hormones.

    • Breast Cancer: A personal history of breast cancer generally precludes the use of hormonal birth control.

    • Uterine Bleeding of Unknown Cause: This needs to be investigated before starting certain methods.

    • Lupus: Some forms of lupus can impact birth control safety.

    • Severe Depression: While not an absolute contraindication, some individuals report mood changes with hormonal birth control, so it’s important to discuss.

  • Medications and Supplements: Create a comprehensive list of all prescription medications, over-the-counter drugs, herbal remedies, and supplements you are currently taking. Some medications can interact with birth control, reducing its effectiveness or increasing side effects. For instance, certain antibiotics or anti-seizure medications can interfere with oral contraceptives.

  • Allergies: List any known allergies to medications, latex, or other materials. This is crucial for barrier methods like condoms or diaphragms.

  • Past Birth Control Experiences:

    • What methods have you used previously?

    • What did you like or dislike about them? For example, “I tried the pill, but I constantly forgot to take it,” or “The patch caused skin irritation.”

    • Did you experience any significant side effects?

    • Were they effective for you?

  • Family Medical History: Certain conditions, like a family history of blood clots, can influence your doctor’s recommendations.

Lifestyle Considerations: Matching Method to Reality

Your daily life plays a huge role in determining the most suitable birth control method. Be honest with yourself and your doctor about these aspects.

Concrete Examples:

  • Memory and Adherence: Are you good at remembering to take a pill every day at the same time? Or would a “set it and forget it” method be more appealing? If you struggle with daily routines, a daily pill might not be the best fit.

  • Convenience and Privacy: Do you prefer a method that doesn’t require daily action, or one that can be used discreetly? For example, an IUD or implant offers long-term, low-maintenance contraception.

  • Sexual Frequency and Partners: How often do you have sex? How many partners do you have? This affects the importance of STI protection. If you have multiple partners or inconsistent sexual activity, a method that also protects against STIs (like condoms) would be highly recommended, perhaps in conjunction with another method for pregnancy prevention.

  • Desire for Future Pregnancy: Do you want children in the future? If so, how soon? Some methods have a quicker return to fertility than others. For example, fertility generally returns quickly after stopping most hormonal methods, but the contraceptive injection (Depo-Provera) can delay return to fertility for up to 18 months.

  • Comfort with Hormones: Are you hesitant about using hormonal methods? Understanding your comfort level helps your doctor explore non-hormonal options.

  • Cost and Insurance Coverage: While most insurance plans cover birth control, specifics can vary. Be prepared to discuss potential costs and what your insurance plan covers. “Will this method be covered by my insurance, and what will my out-of-pocket cost be?” is a perfectly valid question.

  • Cultural or Religious Beliefs: Your personal beliefs might influence your comfort with certain methods. Openly discuss these with your doctor, as they are part of a holistic approach to your care.

Asking the Right Questions: A Collaborative Dialogue

Your doctor is there to educate and guide you, but you need to be an active participant in the conversation. Prepare a list of questions to ensure all your concerns are addressed.

Essential Questions to Ask About Each Method:

When your doctor discusses various options, probe deeper with these questions:

Concrete Examples:

  • Effectiveness: “How effective is this method at preventing pregnancy with typical use? And with perfect use?” Understand the difference – “typical use” accounts for human error, while “perfect use” assumes consistent, flawless application. For example, oral contraceptives are over 99% effective with perfect use, but around 91% with typical use.

  • Mechanism of Action: “How does this method work to prevent pregnancy?” Knowing the science behind it can help you understand potential effects on your body.

  • Common Side Effects: “What are the most common side effects I might experience, and how long do they typically last?” Ask about both hormonal and non-hormonal side effects. For instance, with a hormonal IUD, you might ask about irregular bleeding, mood changes, or acne. For a copper IUD, you might ask about heavier periods or increased cramping.

  • Serious Risks/Contraindications: “Are there any serious risks associated with this method, especially given my health history?” This is where your detailed medical history becomes crucial.

  • Return to Fertility: “If I decide to stop using this method, how quickly can I expect my fertility to return?”

  • Impact on Menstrual Cycle: “How might this method affect my periods – will they become lighter, heavier, more regular, or disappear entirely?”

  • STI Protection: “Does this method protect against sexually transmitted infections?” The answer for most methods is “no,” emphasizing the need for condoms if STI protection is a concern.

  • Ease of Use/Maintenance: “How easy is this method to use, and what kind of maintenance or daily commitment does it require?”

  • Cost and Coverage: “What is the typical cost of this method, and what portion is likely covered by my insurance?”

  • What if I forget/miss a dose (for daily methods)? “What are the steps I need to take if I miss a pill or am late with a patch change?”

  • What if I experience bothersome side effects? “If I start this method and the side effects are too much, what are my options for switching or stopping?”

Tailored Questions Based on Your “Why”

Refer back to your initial reasons for seeking birth control and ask specific questions related to those goals.

Concrete Examples:

  • For period management: “Will this method help with my heavy periods/cramps/irregularity?”

  • For acne: “Is this particular birth control known to improve acne?”

  • For migraines: “Given my history of migraines with aura, which methods are safest and least likely to exacerbate them?”

Understanding Your Options: A Detailed Overview

Your doctor will likely present various categories of birth control. Familiarize yourself with them generally so you can engage more effectively.

Long-Acting Reversible Contraceptives (LARCs)

These methods are highly effective and require minimal user effort once placed.

Concrete Examples:

  • Intrauterine Devices (IUDs):
    • Hormonal IUDs (e.g., Mirena, Skyla, Kyleena, Liletta): Small, T-shaped devices inserted into the uterus that release progestin. They can last 3-8 years depending on the brand. Effectiveness: Over 99% effective. Side Effects: Irregular bleeding or spotting, lighter periods, mood changes, headaches, acne. Many users experience very light or no periods over time.

    • Copper IUD (Paragard): A non-hormonal, T-shaped device inserted into the uterus that releases copper. It can last up to 10-12 years. Effectiveness: Over 99% effective. Side Effects: Heavier, longer, or more painful periods, especially in the first few months. No hormonal side effects.

  • Contraceptive Implant (Nexplanon): A small, flexible rod inserted under the skin of the upper arm, releasing progestin. It lasts up to 3 years. Effectiveness: Over 99% effective. Side Effects: Irregular bleeding, lighter periods or no periods, headaches, mood changes, weight changes.

Short-Acting Hormonal Methods

These require more consistent user action.

Concrete Examples:

  • Birth Control Pills (Oral Contraceptives):
    • Combined Oral Contraceptives (COCs): Contain both estrogen and progestin. Taken daily. Effectiveness: 91% with typical use, over 99% with perfect use. Side Effects: Nausea, breast tenderness, headaches, mood changes, breakthrough bleeding. Can improve acne and period symptoms.

    • Progestin-Only Pills (POPs or Mini-Pills): Contain only progestin. Taken daily at the same time. Effectiveness: 91% with typical use, over 99% with perfect use. Side Effects: Irregular bleeding is common, sometimes no periods. May be suitable for those who cannot take estrogen.

  • Contraceptive Patch (Xulane): A thin, adhesive patch worn on the skin (e.g., abdomen, buttocks, upper arm). A new patch is applied weekly for three weeks, followed by a patch-free week for menstruation. Effectiveness: 91% with typical use, over 99% with perfect use. Side Effects: Similar to COCs, plus skin irritation at the patch site.

  • Vaginal Ring (NuvaRing, Annovera): A flexible ring inserted into the vagina that releases estrogen and progestin. NuvaRing is left in for three weeks, then removed for one week. Annovera is left in for three weeks, removed for one week, and reusable for a year. Effectiveness: 91% with typical use, over 99% with perfect use. Side Effects: Similar to COCs, some users report vaginal irritation or discharge.

  • Contraceptive Injection (Depo-Provera): An injection of progestin given every three months by a healthcare provider. Effectiveness: 94% with typical use, over 99% with perfect use. Side Effects: Irregular bleeding, weight gain, bone density loss (reversible), delayed return to fertility. Many users experience no periods over time.

Barrier Methods

These physically block sperm from reaching the egg and typically offer STI protection.

Concrete Examples:

  • Male Condoms: Worn on the penis. Effectiveness: 87% with typical use (for pregnancy prevention). Highly effective against STIs. Side Effects: Latex allergy, breakage.

  • Female Condoms: Inserted into the vagina. Effectiveness: 79% with typical use. Offers STI protection. Side Effects: Less commonly used, can be noisy.

  • Diaphragm/Cervical Cap: Devices inserted into the vagina before sex, used with spermicide. Requires fitting by a doctor. Effectiveness: 83% (diaphragm) with typical use. Side Effects: UTIs, vaginal irritation, messiness.

  • Contraceptive Sponge: A soft, disposable sponge inserted into the vagina before sex, containing spermicide. Effectiveness: Varies depending on prior pregnancies. Side Effects: Vaginal irritation, messiness.

Fertility Awareness-Based Methods (FABMs) / Natural Family Planning

These involve tracking your menstrual cycle to identify fertile windows and avoiding intercourse during those times.

Concrete Examples:

  • Calendar Method, Basal Body Temperature (BBT) Method, Cervical Mucus Method: Require diligent tracking and understanding of your body’s signs. Effectiveness: Varies widely (76-88% with typical use), highly dependent on consistent and accurate tracking. Side Effects: No physical side effects. Requires significant commitment and partner cooperation.

  • Lactational Amenorrhea Method (LAM): A temporary method for breastfeeding parents under specific conditions (baby less than 6 months, exclusively breastfeeding, and no return of menstruation).

Permanent Methods

These are irreversible options for individuals certain they do not want future pregnancies.

Concrete Examples:

  • Tubal Ligation (for women): “Tying the tubes.” A surgical procedure to block or sever the fallopian tubes. Effectiveness: Over 99% effective.

  • Vasectomy (for men): A surgical procedure to block the tubes that carry sperm. Effectiveness: Over 99% effective.

Advocating for Yourself: Ensuring Your Voice is Heard

Your comfort and preferences are paramount. Don’t hesitate to voice your concerns or assert your choices.

Concrete Examples:

  • Expressing Hesitation: If your doctor suggests a method you’re unsure about, articulate why. “I’m concerned about the potential for weight gain with the injection, as I’ve struggled with my weight in the past.”

  • Requesting More Information: If a method sounds appealing but you have unanswered questions, ask for more details or reliable resources. “Can you tell me more about the insertion process for an IUD, and what the recovery is like?”

  • Seeking Alternatives: If your doctor dismisses a method you’re interested in without a clear medical reason, ask for clarification and other options. “I’ve heard good things about the hormonal IUD, but you seem hesitant to recommend it for me. Could you explain your concerns more fully, and are there other LARC options we could discuss?”

  • If You Feel Unheard: If you feel your concerns are not being addressed or your doctor is pushing a method you’re uncomfortable with, politely state, “I appreciate your recommendation, but I’d like to explore other options that might align better with my lifestyle/preferences.” If necessary, consider seeking a second opinion. You have the right to informed consent and to choose a method that feels right for you.

  • Bringing a Support Person: Sometimes, having a trusted friend or family member with you can help you remember questions and feel more confident in the discussion.

Post-Appointment: What to Do Next

The conversation doesn’t end when you leave the office.

Concrete Examples:

  • Clarify Instructions: Before you leave, ensure you fully understand how to use your chosen method, including dosage, frequency, and what to do if you miss a dose or application. Ask for written instructions if available. “Can you walk me through the exact steps for taking this pill daily, and what to do if I miss one?”

  • Understand Follow-Up: Ask about necessary follow-up appointments, especially for methods like IUDs or implants that require insertion and subsequent checks.

  • Monitor for Side Effects: Be aware of the common side effects and when to contact your doctor if they are severe or persistent. Keep a journal if helpful.

  • Review and Reassess: Birth control needs can change over time. Your doctor should be a long-term partner in your reproductive health. If your current method isn’t working, or your life circumstances change, schedule another appointment to discuss alternatives. For example, if you start a new relationship and want STI protection in addition to pregnancy prevention, you’d discuss incorporating condoms.

Conclusion

Discussing birth control with your doctor is a crucial step in taking control of your reproductive health. By understanding your motivations, meticulously preparing your health and lifestyle information, asking targeted questions, and confidently advocating for your preferences, you transform a potentially daunting conversation into an empowering dialogue. Remember, the goal is a collaborative partnership with your healthcare provider to find a birth control method that not only prevents pregnancy effectively but also enhances your overall well-being and aligns seamlessly with your life.